Politics · Philippines Bureau
Impeachment court orders Sara Duterte's spokesman to explain remarks accusing senator-judges of bias
The Senate tribunal issued a show-cause order against lawyer Paolo Panelo on Day 45 of the Vice President's trial, as defence witnesses testified on the registration of Cale88 Foods, a company linked to her husband.
LSN Philippines ·

<p>The Senate impeachment court on Friday, 20 November, ordered Vice President Sara Duterte's spokesman, lawyer Paolo Panelo, to explain why he should not be cited for contempt over public remarks accusing several senator-judges of bias.</p>
<p>Presiding Officer Senator Francis "Chiz" Escudero approved, without objection, a motion by Senator-Judge Erwin Tulfo to issue a show-cause order, according to the Philippine News Agency, Rappler and ABS-CBN News.</p>
<p>The order stems from comments Panelo made on Thursday after senator-judges questioned defence witness Rainer Dela Fuente, a former Anti-Money Laundering Council (AMLC) official. Panelo said Senator-Judges Risa Hontiveros, Francis Pangilinan and Raffy Tulfo had shown bias against the Vice President and were acting like prosecutors, arguing that challenging a defence witness's credibility was the prosecution's job.</p>
<p>Escudero said Panelo was not covered by the court's own sub judice rule because he is not a party, a lawyer of record or a witness in the case. He said, however, that the court could still exercise authority over him under Rule 71 of the Rules of Court on contempt, which applies to the trial in a supplementary way. The Philippine News Agency noted that the order gives Panelo a chance to explain and is not a finding of contempt.</p>
<p>Tulfo told the court that Panelo, as spokesman for the official on trial, should exercise restraint. "He's not party to this case, but he is the spokesman for the Vice President," he said, as quoted by The Manila Times.</p>
<p>Panelo said in a statement that his remarks were protected by the Constitution and cited Supreme Court rulings on the right to criticise judicial bodies. "I welcome the opportunity to demonstrate that my comments were fair, made in good faith, and did not impede, obstruct, or degrade the administration of justice, and are thus constitutionally protected," he said, according to the Inquirer and The Manila Times. He said he would file a formal reply within the prescribed period once he receives the order.</p>
<p>Testimony on Cale88</p>
<p>The defence continued presenting witnesses on Cale88 Foods Corp., a banana chips company linked to the Vice President's husband, lawyer Manases Carpio. The firm came under scrutiny after AMLC testimony presented by the prosecution that it received around P319 million in remittances from China, the Inquirer reported. The defence says the company is engaged in a lawful and legitimate business of producing and exporting banana chips.</p>
<p>Trade Undersecretary Ceferino Rodolfo, who also heads the Board of Investments (BOI), testified that Cale88 is registered with the BOI as an export enterprise, a status that requires a company to export at least 70 per cent of its output. Asked whether the BOI found any issue with the company's China-related exports, he said it had not, as far as the export requirement was concerned, according to the Inquirer.</p>
<p>Under questioning from Senator-Judge Sherwin Gatchalian, Rodolfo confirmed audited sales of P208 million for 2022 to 2025, GMA News reported. Gatchalian then cited AMLC data showing inflows to the company of P776 million against outflows of about P154.6 million.</p>
<p>Food and Drug Administration official Pilar Marilyn Pagayunan, director of its Center for Food Regulation and Research, testified that the agency issued Cale88 product registrations for its sweetened banana chips, but said registration does not show whether a company actually manufactured, sold or exported a product. "I cannot testify whether they actually manufactured or sold the product because that is beyond the mandate of our office," she said, as quoted by The Manila Times.</p>
<p>The impeachment court was expected to release its schedule for the next hearings as the Senate prepares to take up the 2027 national budget next week.</p>