Politics · Philippines Bureau
Lawmaker defends voided seafarers' law provisions as industry safeguard
A congressman who authored the Magna Carta of Filipino Seafarers has defended provisions struck down by the Supreme Court, arguing they were designed to maintain fair competition in the maritime sector.
LSN Philippines ·

MANILA — Tingog Party-list Representative Jude Acidre has pushed back against the Supreme Court's decision to invalidate certain provisions of Republic Act No. 12021, the Magna Carta of Filipino Seafarers, saying lawmakers included them to protect industry balance and competitiveness.
Acidre, one of the law's principal authors, made the statement Tuesday following the high court's ruling that the challenged provisions were unconstitutional. He maintained that the disputed clauses were carefully crafted measures intended to serve the interests of Filipino seafarers while maintaining equilibrium within the maritime industry.
The Magna Carta of Filipino Seafarers, which seeks to enhance protections and benefits for Filipinos working at sea, has become the subject of constitutional scrutiny over specific regulatory measures. Acidre's defense underscores ongoing tensions between legislative attempts to strengthen seafarer protections and constitutional limitations on such measures.
The case highlights the complex balance lawmakers must strike when crafting employment protections, particularly in specialized industries like maritime services where international standards and domestic regulations intersect. Acidre's comments suggest the administration may consider alternative legislative approaches to achieve similar protective goals within constitutional bounds.