Business · Vietnam Bureau
Muong Thanh tycoon Le Thanh Than goes on trial in Hanoi over 519 apartments sold without ownership papers
The 76-year-old founder of the Muong Thanh hotel group admitted in court that buyers at the CT6 Kien Hung project were given false information, and offered either replacement homes or refunds.
LSN Vietnam ·

<p>Le Thanh Than, chairman of Vietnam's Muong Thanh Group, went on trial at the Hanoi People's Court on Wednesday, 18 November, charged with deceiving customers at an apartment project where 519 buyers have waited more than a decade for legal ownership of their homes.</p>
<p>Than, 76, is being tried in his capacity as chairman and general director of Bemes, the developer of the CT6 Kien Hung complex in Hanoi's former Ha Dong district. Five former officials of Kien Hung ward are standing trial alongside him on charges of negligence causing serious consequences, according to the state newspaper Nhan Dan and the procuracy's newspaper Bao Ve Phap Luat.</p>
<p>According to the indictment, from March 2011 the developer advertised that the project had been approved, that its design met building rules and that apartment prices included land-use rights, persuading people to sign purchase contracts. Prosecutors say Than at the same time ordered the project built far outside its approved plan: buildings were made larger and taller, extra flats were added, and a whole additional tower, CT6C, was put up without approval. The low-rise section was also expanded beyond its permitted footprint.</p>
<p>The complex was completed in November 2012 and handed over to residents in January 2013. Because of the violations, the 519 flats sold do not qualify for land-use and ownership certificates, known in Vietnam as "red books". Investigators put Than's illicit gains, and the buyers' losses, at more than VND531 billion (roughly US$20 million).</p>
<p>During questioning on Wednesday, Than admitted that he had given customers untrue information and told the judging panel that the charge brought by prosecutors was correct, state broadcaster VTV reported. He proposed two ways to compensate buyers: moving those who want it to homes at the Thanh Ha urban area, or refunding those who prefer their money back. He said about VND530 billion had been transferred to the judgment enforcement agency's account the day before the trial opened.</p>
<p>The case has taken years to reach court. Than was first prosecuted seven years ago, and the file went through eight rounds of supplementary investigation and one earlier hearing that was sent back. The court has summoned all 519 buyers as victims along with around 200 other individuals and organisations with related interests, and the trial is scheduled to run until 30 November.</p>
<p>The trial comes a day after Hanoi authorities set deadlines to relocate residents from violating flats at 12 Muong Thanh-linked projects by the end of 2027.</p>
<p>Sources: Nhan Dan, VTV, Bao Ve Phap Luat, ANTV, VnExpress.</p>